17 Bizarre American Foods You've Never Heard Of: A Culinary Road Trip Adventure

Charles (Chuck) Sieber

9/7/2024

Hey there, fellow food adventurers! Chuck here from American Travel Fun, and do I have a treat for you today. We're about to embark on a culinary road trip through some of the strangest, most bizarre, and downright crazy foods America has to offer.

Now, let us check out the weird and wonderful dishes that make up America's quirky food landscape. I'm not saying you should try them all (looking at you, roadkill stew), but hey, where's the fun in playing it safe?

A Note on Food Images:

To enhance the visual appeal of this post, I've used AI-generated images for some of the dishes. Please note that while the descriptions, facts, and locations are accurate, not all photos are real. Labels will indicate whether an image is AI-Generated or a Real Photograph. For instance, the Battered Fried Rattle Snake image is AI-created, while the Rocky Mountain Oysters photo is authentic.

AI-Generated

Real Photograph

1. Roadkill Delights

Yep, you read that right. In Montana, they're turning highway casualties into cuisine. Now, before you go swerving to hit Bambi, let me explain. This isn't your typical "scrape it off the asphalt" fare. We're talking carefully prepared dishes using animals that met an untimely end on the road.

Weird fact: In West Virginia, there's actually a law allowing motorists to take home and eat roadkill they've accidentally hit.

History: This practice has its roots in the waste-not-want-not attitude of rural America, especially during the Great Depression. These days, it's seeing a resurgence among eco-conscious foodies looking to reduce waste. Who knew being green could be so... gamey?

If you're feeling extra adventurous, head to the Illinois State Fair for their deep-fried "roadkill" - it's actually just dough shaped like a flattened possum, complete with berry "blood" syrup. Yum?

AI-Generated

2. Gator on a Stick

Next stop on our culinary adventure: the bayous of Louisiana! Here, you'll find a snack that bites back - fried alligator on a stick. It's like a chicken nugget, but with more teeth.

Weird fact: Alligator meat is actually healthier than beef, with more protein and less saturated fat. Who knew swamp food could be a superfood?

History: Alligator has been a staple in Cajun and Creole cooking for centuries, but it wasn't until the 1980s when alligator farming was legalized that it became more widely available. Now, you can chomp on these prehistoric treats at food festivals across the South and even at the Illinois State Fair.

My take: I haven't tried this one yet, but it's high on my list. I mean, how often do you get to say you ate a creature that's been around since the dinosaurs?

AI-Generated

3. The Cheese That Isn't

Alright, cheese lovers, brace yourselves. We're heading to St. Louis, Missouri, home of Provel cheese - a cheese so unique, it's not legally considered cheese by the FDA. It's like the rebel of the dairy world.

Weird fact: Provel is a blend of cheddar, Swiss, and provolone, with a hint of liquid smoke. It's specifically designed to melt without stringing, making it perfect for St. Louis-style pizza.

History: Created in the 1950s, Provel has become such a St. Louis staple that expats often have it shipped to them when they move away.

My take: This one sounds delicious to me. I mean, a blend of three amazing cheeses with a smoky kick? Sign me up! I can already imagine it melted over some crispy nachos or a meaty pizza. Mmmm...

Real Photograph

4. Military-Grade Comfort Food

Now, let's talk about a dish with a name that's sure to raise eyebrows - Shit on a Shingle, or SOS for short. Don't worry, it's more appetizing than it sounds!

Weird fact: This dish got its colorful name from World War II soldiers, who thought the creamy beef mixture on toast resembled, well... you get the idea.

History: SOS started as a military staple but found its way into civilian life after the war. It's basically chipped beef in a creamy sauce served over toast - a simple, filling meal that's become a nostalgic comfort food for many.

My take: I've had something similar, just spiced up a bit more. It's not fancy, but it's the kind of stick-to-your-ribs meal that hits the spot after a long day of traveling.

Real Photograph

5. Hop to It: Frog Legs

Jumping (pun intended) from military mess halls to fancy French-inspired cuisine, let's talk about frog legs. These little amphibian delicacies have been hopping onto American plates since the 1920s.

Weird fact: Some people experience a slight numbing sensation in their mouth after eating frog legs. It's like a built-in after-dinner party trick!

History: While often associated with French cuisine, frog legs gained popularity in America during the Roaring Twenties as a sophisticated, cosmopolitan dish. Today, you can find them in various preparations across the country, especially in the South.

My take: I've tried them, and people are right about the chicken taste. They're similar to chicken, but with a greasier texture.

Real Photograph

6. Rattlin' Good Eats

We're moseying on down to Oklahoma for a taste of the Wild West - deep-fried rattlesnake. It's the ultimate "eat or be eaten" scenario.

Weird fact: Rattlesnake meat can only be legally sold in the U.S. if the snake was killed in a state where it's not considered an endangered species. Talk about locally sourced!

History: Native American tribes have been consuming rattlesnake meat for centuries. In modern times, it's become a novelty food often associated with cowboy cuisine and Wild West festivals.

My take: This is definitely on my bucket list. I mean, how many people can say they've eaten a rattlesnake? Plus, I hear it's actually pretty healthy - high in protein and low in fat. It's like nature's protein bar!

AI-Generated

7. Chocolate Meets Crunch

Now, for all you adventurous dessert lovers out there, we're hopping over to Colorado for a sweet and crunchy treat - chocolate-covered grasshoppers. It's like a protein bar met a candy bar and had a really weird baby.

Weird fact: Eating insects, including grasshoppers, could help reduce greenhouse gas emissions compared to traditional livestock farming. So you can satisfy your sweet tooth and save the planet at the same time!

History: While insects have been part of traditional diets in many cultures, chocolate-covered insects gained popularity in the U.S. as a novelty item in the late 20th century. Recently, they've seen increased interest due to the growing focus on sustainable protein sources.

My take: I haven't tried these yet, but I'm oddly curious. I mean, if you close your eyes, it's just a really crunchy chocolate bar, right? ...Right?

Real Photograph

8. A Tongue-Twisting Delicacy

Let's roll out the red carpet for this next dish - beef tongue. Popular in Texas and Hawaii, this dish might make you think twice before sticking out your own tongue!

Weird fact: A single cow's tongue can weigh up to 3 pounds and contain over 3,000 taste buds.

History: Beef tongue has been a staple in many cultures, including Jewish and Mexican cuisines. In America, it was popular during the early 20th century but fell out of favor as more choice cuts became widely available. Recently, it's seen a resurgence among adventurous eaters and in traditional ethnic cuisines.

My take: I'm on the fence about this one. The idea of eating a tongue is a bit... tongue-tying. But I've heard it's incredibly tender and flavorful when prepared right. Maybe I'll give it a try... someday. Maybe!

Real Photograph

9. Desert on a Plate

Next up, we're heading to the Southwest for a prickly treat - cactus fries! It's like the desert decided to compete with French fries, and honestly, it's not doing too badly.

Weird fact: Cactus pads, known as nopales, can help lower blood sugar levels and are used in traditional medicine to treat diabetes. Who knew your side dish could double as a health supplement?

History: Cactus has been a staple food in Mexican and Native American cuisines for centuries. Cactus fries are a modern, Americanized adaptation that gained popularity in the Southwest in recent decades as interest in regional and health-conscious cuisines grew.

My take: This is one I'm really excited to try! A healthier alternative to regular fries that's unique and packed with Southwestern flavor? I'm in!

Real Photograph

10. Mind-Blowing Sandwich

Alright, folks, brace yourselves for this next one. We're heading to parts of the Midwest for a dish that's sure to get your neurons firing - the brain sandwich. Yes, you read that right. It's a sandwich. Made of brains.

Weird fact: Some restaurants stopped serving brain sandwiches due to concerns about mad cow disease, but a few places still offer them using pig brains instead. Because apparently, that makes it all better?

History: Brain sandwiches were once common in many parts of the U.S., particularly in areas with strong German influences. They were especially popular in the Midwest during the early 20th century. Their popularity declined sharply in the late 20th century due to health concerns and changing tastes.

My take: I'm going to be honest, this one's a hard pass for me. I like my food to not think back. But hey, if you're feeling brainy, who am I to judge?

Real Photograph

11. Southern Soda Pop Snack

Now, let's head down South for a snack that's sure to raise some eyebrows - peanuts in Coke. Yep, Peanuts. In. Coke.

Weird fact: This combination was born out of necessity - it was a quick, one-handed snack for blue-collar workers who didn't have time for a lunch break!

History: This quirky tradition dates back to the 1920s when workers would pour peanuts into their Coke bottles to have a snack and a drink without getting their hands dirty. It became popular among farmers, truck drivers, and manual laborers before spreading to wider Southern culture.

My take: I've seen my father-in-law do this, and I still can't wrap my head around it. The idea of fizzy, peanutty Coke just doesn't compute for me. But hey, don't knock it till you've tried it, right?

AI-Generated

12. Gravy with a Kick

Next up on our culinary road trip, we're stopping in the South for a gravy that'll wake you right up - Red Eye Gravy, also known as Poor Man's Gravy.

Weird fact: The name "red eye" comes from the reddish circle of fat that forms on the surface of the gravy, resembling a bloodshot eye. Talk about eye-catching!

History: This gravy originated in the early 19th century among poor Southern households as a way to use every part of the ham and stretch meals. Legend has it that Andrew Jackson once asked his hungover cook for gravy as red as his eyes, leading to the name.

My take: I've never tried this one, but I'm intrigued. Coffee and ham drippings? It's like breakfast and dinner had a baby. I can see how it might be an acquired taste, but hey, I'm always up for a culinary adventure!

Real Photograph

13. Rochester's Finest Mess

Alright, food lovers, buckle up because we're heading to Rochester, New York, for a dish that's as bizarre as it is beloved - the Garbage Plate. Don't let the name fool you; this is a local delicacy that's anything but trash.

Weird fact: The Garbage Plate is so popular in Rochester that it's been served at weddings. Now that's true love!

History: Created in 1918 at Nick Tahou Hots in Rochester, NY, this dish was originally called "Hots and Potatoes". It got its current name when college students asked for a plate with "all the garbage" on it. Since then, it's become a late-night staple and a source of local pride.

My take: I've got to admit, this one scares me a little. It's like someone raided the fridge at 2 AM and piled everything onto one plate. But you know what? Sometimes those weird midnight snacks turn out to be the best.

Credit: Eugene Peretz from Northampton, MA, USA - Garbage plate

Real Photograph

14. Pickled Peculiarity

Our next stop takes us to the world of pickled provisions. Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you: Pickled Pig's Feet. We're talking about actual pig trotters, pickled to perfection.

Weird fact: Believe it or not, pickled pig feet are sometimes used as a hangover cure due to their high protein and salt content. Move over, greasy breakfast!

History: This dish has deep roots in Southern soul food and gained popularity during the Great Depression as an affordable source of protein. Today, it remains a beloved snack in some African American and rural Southern communities.

My take: I've seen these in stores, and I've got to be honest - they kind of creep me out. The idea of biting into a pickled toe is a bit much for me. But who knows? Maybe after a long night out, I might find myself reaching for a jar. Stranger things have happened!

Real Photograph

15. Kentucky's Kitchen Sink Stew

Next, we're stirring up trouble in Kentucky with a dish that's part mystery, part history - Burgoo. This hearty stew is like the "everything but the kitchen sink" of the culinary world.

Weird fact: Traditional burgoo was said to be ready when a spoon could stand up straight in the pot due to its thickness. Now that's what I call a stick-to-your-ribs meal!

History: Burgoo has its roots in the early 19th century and was often made in large batches for community gatherings and political rallies. It evolved from being a hunter's stew to a beloved regional dish, with each community guarding its secret recipe.

My take: I've got to admit, the idea of a stew with squirrel, possum, and raccoon is a bit out there for me.

Real Photograph

16. Rocky Mountain Surprise

Hold onto your hats, folks, because our next stop is the Wild West, where we're diving into a plate of Rocky Mountain Oysters. Spoiler alert: these aren't seafood.

Weird fact: These are sometimes called "cowboy caviar" or "swinging beef" as humorous euphemisms. Gotta love that cowboy humor!

History: This dish originated among ranchers who practiced animal husbandry. Instead of wasting the byproducts of cattle castration, they turned them into a protein-rich meal. Over time, it became a novelty food at festivals and bars, often used as a rite of passage or dare for tourists.

My take: I'm going to be blunt here - this is the most stomach-turning item on our list for me. The idea of eating bull testicles, no matter how they're prepared, is just not something I can wrap my head (or mouth) around. But hey, if you're feeling brave and want to earn some serious cowboy cred, go for it! Just maybe don't tell me about it afterwards, okay?

Real Photograph

17. Soul Food Specialty

For our final stop on this wild culinary journey, we're diving deep into soul food territory with a dish that's got a lot of guts - quite literally. Ladies and gentlemen, I give you: Chitterlings, or as they're affectionately known, Chitlins.

Weird fact: The smell during cooking is so strong that some people cook chitlins outdoors or use a special "chitlin pot" to contain the odor. This dish has presence!

History: Chitlins have roots in slave cuisine, where enslaved people were often given the less desirable parts of the pig. They became a staple of soul food and remain an important part of African American culinary tradition, especially during holidays.

My take: I've smelled these cooking before, and it was an experience. The aroma is... intense, to put it mildly. I have to admit, I haven't been brave enough to try them yet. For me, food has to smell good to be appetizing. But I respect the history behind this dish and the skill it takes to prepare it properly. Maybe someday I'll work up the courage to give them a try. Maybe.

Real Photograph

Wrapping Up Our Bizarre Food Road Trip

Well, folks, we've come to the end of our journey through America's weirdest and most wonderful regional dishes. From roadkill stew to chocolate-covered insects, from organs to oddities, we've explored the length and breadth of our nation's quirky food landscape.

These dishes might not all appeal to everyone's taste buds (I'm looking at you, Rocky Mountain Oysters), but they're all important pieces of America's diverse culinary tapestry. They tell stories of resourcefulness, cultural heritage, and regional pride. They remind us that food is more than just sustenance - it's a window into history, culture, and community.

So the next time you're on a road trip, why not spice things up by trying a local specialty? You might discover a new favorite, or at the very least, you'll have a great story to tell. Just remember, when it comes to bizarre foods, sometimes it's better to eat first and ask questions later!

What's the strangest food you've ever tried on your travels? Drop a comment below and let me know! And if you're brave enough to try any of these dishes, I want to hear all about it (well, maybe not all about it in some cases).

Until next time, have fun!

FAQs About Bizarre American Foods

Q: Are these foods safe to eat? A: While these foods might seem unusual, they are generally prepared following food safety guidelines. However, always ensure you're getting them from reputable sources.
Q: Where can I try these foods? A: Many of these dishes are regional specialties. Your best bet is to try them in their place of origin or at state fairs and food festivals.
Q: Are any of these foods endangered species? A: No, none of these foods come from endangered species. However, some, like rattlesnake meat, may have restrictions on where they can be sourced from.
Q: Are there vegetarian options for bizarre American foods? A: While many of these are meat-based, options like cactus fries offer a unique vegetarian experience. There are also many unusual plant-based regional specialties not covered in this list.
Q: How do I prepare my stomach for trying these unusual foods? A: Start small and listen to your body. It's okay to just take a taste! Consider having some antacids on hand, just in case.

Remember, the joy of culinary exploration is in the experience. Whether you love or hate these bizarre foods, you're sure to come away with a story to tell!